The Race for Rare Earths: Who Controls the Future of Clean Energy?

 The Race for Rare Earths: Who Controls the Future of Clean Energy?

Introduction: The Hidden Backbone of Modern Technology

Electric cars. Smartphones. Wind turbines. Satellites. Military defense systems.

These marvels of modern innovation all share a common lifeline—rare earth elements. Despite their name, rare earths are not all that rare; what makes them precious is the fact that they are hard to mine, harder to refine, and even harder to distribute equitably.

As the world races toward a clean energy transition, demand for rare earths is exploding. But so are geopolitical tensions, environmental concerns, and ethical dilemmas. At the center of this global tug-of-war lies a critical question:

Who controls the raw materials of the future—and at what cost?

1. What Are Rare Earth Elements, and Why Are They Important?

Rare earth elements (REEs) refer to 17 metallic elements on the periodic table, including neodymium, dysprosium, lanthanum, and others. These are essential for producing:

• Magnets used in electric motors and wind turbines

• Batteries for electric vehicles (EVs)

• Lasers, fiber optics, and semiconductors

• LEDs and touchscreens

• Guidance systems and radar in military technology

These elements are not easily substitutable. Without them, the clean energy transition and digital infrastructure would grind to a halt.

🔋 Example:

• An average Tesla Model 3 contains about 1 kg of rare earth magnets

• A single 3-megawatt wind turbine uses over 600 kg of rare earth elements

As we move toward carbon neutrality, the green economy is becoming a mineral economy.

2. The Global Supply Chain: Dominated by One

Today, more than 85% of the world’s rare earth refining capacity is controlled by China.

China not only dominates mining but has mastered the complex chemical processes required to refine and separate rare earths—a stage that is extremely hazardous and expensive elsewhere.

Top Players in the Supply Chain:

• 🇨🇳 China: Controls production, refining, and export; has used rare earths as a geopolitical tool in trade disputes

• 🇺🇸 United States: Owns one major rare earth mine (Mountain Pass, California) but sends most of its ore to China for processing

• 🇦🇺 Australia: Home to Lynas Corporation, one of the few non-Chinese rare earth producers

• 🌍 Africa (DR Congo, Madagascar): Rich in rare earth potential but plagued by governance and infrastructure issues

This imbalance makes the world dangerously dependent on a single country for materials essential to economic and national security.

3. The Geopolitics of Green Energy

The energy wars of the 20th century were about oil and gas. The energy wars of the 21st may well be about lithium, cobalt, and rare earths.

Key Geopolitical Flashpoints:

• U.S.–China Trade Tensions: In 2019, China threatened to cut off rare earth supplies during the trade war with the U.S., highlighting their strategic leverage.

• European Union’s Strategic Autonomy Plan: The EU has called rare earths a “strategic vulnerability” and is investing billions in domestic and African supply chains.

• Russia and Central Asia: These regions hold significant untapped reserves, and China has begun investing heavily in their development.

Strategic Moves:

• Japan has funded exploration in Vietnam and Kazakhstan.

• India is investing in its own REE refining capabilities.

• The U.S. Department of Defense is now directly supporting rare earth mining projects on U.S. soil.

The green revolution is colliding with old-school resource nationalism—and the result could reshape global alliances.

4. The Environmental and Human Cost of Extraction

Rare earths may power green technologies, but their extraction is anything but green.

Environmental Impacts:

• Mining generates radioactive waste, especially thorium and uranium

• Soil and water contamination is common near mines

• Refining uses toxic chemicals and vast amounts of water

• Tailings (waste material) can devastate ecosystems for decades

Case Study: Baotou, China

• Known as the “capital of rare earths,” Baotou has paid the price for global demand.

• The nearby tailings lake is toxic, black, and lifeless.

• Local residents suffer from high rates of respiratory and cancer-related illnesses.

Human Rights Concerns:

• In places like the Democratic Republic of Congo, child labor and poor working conditions plague artisanal mining sectors

• Indigenous communities often face land grabs and displacement

• Lack of regulation in developing nations allows environmental abuses and corruption

Thus, a core paradox: clean energy must not come at the cost of dirty mining.

5. Recycling and Alternatives: Can We Break the Chain?

To reduce dependence and environmental impact, researchers are exploring recycling and substitution.

♻️ Recycling Rare Earths:

• Currently, less than 1% of rare earths are recycled

• Old electronics, wind turbines, and EV batteries could be a major secondary source

• The challenge lies in recovering rare earths efficiently and cost-effectively

🔄 Substitution:

• Companies like Tesla are exploring motors that use fewer or no rare earths

• Researchers are developing bioleaching methods using microbes to extract rare earths with less pollution

🧠 Innovation Needed:

• A future-proof supply chain must include:

  • Urban mining (harvesting materials from waste)

  • Circular economy design in electronics and vehicles

  • Public-private partnerships to fund cleaner technologies

But time is running out. Demand is projected to increase five-fold by 2030—especially as developing countries electrify and digitize.

6. Building a Just and Resilient Rare Earth Economy

To move forward responsibly, the world must strike a delicate balance between security, sustainability, and equity.

What Governments Must Do:

• Enforce strict environmental standards for domestic and imported rare earths

• Subsidize research into alternatives and recycling

• Build transparent, ethical supply chains in partnership with Global South nations

What Companies Can Do:

• Conduct full lifecycle assessments of rare earths in their products

• Ensure ethical sourcing through third-party certification

• Invest in recovery and reuse technologies as part of product design

What Global Institutions Can Do:

• Create a rare earths traceability system, similar to “conflict-free diamonds”

• Include rare earth ethics in climate financing mechanisms

• Support resource-rich but underdeveloped nations in benefitting fairly from their minerals

Without intentional reform, the clean energy revolution could become just another chapter in exploitative resource extraction.

Conclusion: Who Owns the Future?

Rare earths are the unsung heroes—and villains—of our technological age. They power progress, but they also threaten to divide the world along old lines: those who control resources, and those who are controlled by them.

As we race toward a net-zero carbon future, we must not trade one form of planetary harm for another.

The question is not just who wins the race for rare earths, but whether we can win it without losing sight of ethics, environment, and equality.

Because in the end, a green future must also be a just future—or it’s no future at all.

July 11, 2025

Subscribe by Email

Follow Updates Articles from This Blog via Email